The battle between Israel and Hamas has turned some uncommon comrades into political allies. However the strangest mixture on show thus far might be “Queers for Palestine,” particularly since these protesters would danger abstract execution in the event that they took their demonstration to the Gaza Strip.
The motion isn’t new. However following the terrorist assaults on Israel by Hamas, the Palestinian group that controls Gaza, the nation has seen one thing of a resurgence in a number of protests. “Queer rights! Trans rights!” Protesters are heard chanting in a video recorded in New York Metropolis. “We are saying no to genocide!”
That protesters appear responsible Israel for these assaults – which embody Hamas militants killing folks, filming it and posting the video on social media for the deceased’s household and associates to see – is perverse. However to mix that problem with LGBT rights is just disconnected from actuality.
Homosexual and transgender folks – each in Gaza and the West Financial institution – face a rare degree of persecution, persecution that may end up in years in jail and even demise.
In 2016, Hamas militants executed one in every of their very own commanders, Mahmoud Ishtiwi, for allegedly having intercourse with one other man. Ishtiwi’s loyalty to the group was clear: simply two years earlier he had performed the identical below the management 1,000 troopers and an assortment of assault tunnels. However even his loyalty could not save him after they made accusations that he had engaged in gay actions. Earlier than executing him with three bullets within the chest, Hamas reportedly tortured him by beating him, hanging him from the ceiling for hours and enjoying loud music in his cell to deprive him of sleep.
Final yr, the severed head of 25-year-old Ahmed Abu Marhia was discovered on the aspect of the street within the West Financial institution after he was murdered for being gay. The killer filmed the execution and shared it on social media.
In relation to ‘Queers for Palestine’, it is vitally ironic that many LGBT Palestinians do searching for asylum in Israel– the identical nation that protesters in the USA are opposing.
On the coronary heart of this contradiction is the tendency in social justice actions to decide on a transparent protagonist and antagonist, the oppressed and the oppressors, and transfer ahead from there in a one-size-fits-all method. Some progressives determined way back that Palestine is the primary and Israel is the final, which is the seed from which every part should develop. Palestine due to this fact not solely stands for anti-colonialism, but in addition for LGBT rights reproductive rightseven if these rights, in any significant sense of the phrase, don’t really exist there.
In the meantime, this orthodoxy requires Israel to represent a weed and all that comes with it. So the nation should be a logo of genocide, no matter the truth that it has been the sufferer of brutal terrorist assaults this month. And it should symbolize hostility in direction of minorities, together with homosexuals and transgender folks, regardless of being probably the most tolerant societies for these very folks.
To be truthful, the Israeli authorities isn’t excellent. There are facets of the Israeli-Palestinian debate and territorial disputes which can be extra advanced than many would most likely prefer to admit. This side? Not a lot, as a result of “Queers for Palestine” is about as compelling as “mink for fur coats.”
The submit The Contradictions of ‘Queers for Palestine’ first appeared on Cause.com.